How to Bundle Auto and Renters Insurance in NJ for Big Savings

When it comes to saving money on insurance, every dollar counts. And if you're living in New Jersey, there's a smart move that many people overlook — bundling your policies. Pairing your auto and renters insurance into a single package isn’t just convenient, it can actually put more cash back in your pocket. In this blog, we’ll break down exactly how an auto and renters insurance bundle works, who should consider it, and how much you could save when you bundle with Defy Insurance.

Let’s dive in.

What Is an Auto and Renters Insurance Bundle?

An auto and renters insurance bundle simply means you get both policies from the same insurance provider — and as a reward, you usually get a multi-policy discount. Instead of managing two separate companies and bills, you combine everything under one roof. That means one monthly payment, one point of contact, and a smoother experience overall.

But beyond the simplicity, it’s the savings that really make it worth it. Most providers, including Defy Insurance, offer discounts when you bundle your auto premiums and renters coverage together. It’s a win-win.

And the best part? You don’t need to own a house to enjoy these savings. Renters can benefit just as much — sometimes even more — than homeowners.

Explore our Auto Insurance options

Benefits of Bundling Your Policies in New Jersey

Bundling isn’t just about shaving a few bucks off your bill. Here’s what you actually get when you combine your auto and renters insurance in NJ:

• Real savings: Most insurance companies offer a multi-policy discount when you bundle. That means lower auto premiums and cheaper renters coverage.
• Fewer headaches: You deal with just one company. Less paperwork, fewer logins, and way easier to manage.
• Better customer support: Having multiple policies with the same provider often means faster service and more personalized help.
• Stronger protection: Bundling can sometimes give you access to extra perks like accident forgiveness or enhanced bundling options.
• Consistency: Policies renew at the same time, which makes planning ahead easier.

In New Jersey, where the cost of living is already high, bundling is one of those small moves that can make a big impact over time.

Who Should Consider Bundling?

Honestly? Most people.

If you rent an apartment, condo, or house — and you own a car — you're a perfect fit for an auto and renters insurance bundle. This setup is especially helpful for:

• College students living off-campus
• Young professionals renting in the city
• Families in transition between homes
• People who just like to keep things simple

Even if you already have both policies from different companies, it’s worth comparing your current setup to a bundle from Defy Insurance. You might be surprised how much you’re leaving on the table.

Review our Renters Insurance coverage

How Much Can You Save by Bundling Insurance?

Let’s talk numbers — because that’s really what matters here.

While exact savings depend on your location, coverage limits, driving record, and a few other things, people in New Jersey typically save anywhere from 10% to 25% by bundling. That could be hundreds of dollars every year just by combining your auto premiums with your renters coverage.

Here’s a quick example:

Say you’re paying $1,000/year for car insurance and $250/year for renters insurance. A 15% multi-policy discount on both would knock off $187.50 a year. Not bad for a move that takes 15 minutes.

And those aren’t made-up numbers — we’ve seen many customers cut their bills just like that.

Oh, and keep in mind: the more policies you bundle (think motorcycle, umbrella, or even life insurance), the more you can save. But even sticking to just auto and renters insurance bundle is a smart first step.

Example Bundle Scenarios

Still unsure if bundling is the right move for you? Let’s walk through a few real-life situations where combining auto and renters insurance bundle makes total sense — and shows how easy it is to benefit.

1. Sarah – Young Professional in Jersey City

Sarah just moved into a new apartment near her job and owns a small sedan. She had her car insured with one company and just picked up renters insurance through another. When she spoke with Defy Insurance, she realized she could save nearly 20% just by switching both policies over to one provider. Her auto premiums dropped slightly, and her renters coverage came out to less than $10/month. Now, she manages both through one app and loves how stress-free it is.

2. Alex – College Student in Newark

Alex doesn’t own much — just a laptop, a bike, and a few essentials in his off-campus apartment. But he also just bought a used car to get around more easily. Instead of buying separate coverage, he went with a bundle from Defy Insurance. His multi-policy discount helped lower his monthly bill, and he got basic renters coverage that protects his things without overpaying.

3. Melissa and Jake – Couple Renting in Hoboken

Melissa and Jake live together in a rental and each have a car. Defy Insurance helped them combine all three policies — two cars and renters insurance — into one package. Not only did they get the bundling discount, but they also qualified for extra perks like roadside assistance and accident forgiveness. Total savings? About $300 per year.

As you can see, whether you live alone or with a partner, rent a small studio or a larger space, bundling your insurance is a smart, flexible option.

Steps to Bundle with Defy Insurance

Bundling with Defy Insurance is quick, easy, and totally free to explore. Here's how it works:

1. Get a Quote – Head over to our site or give us a call. We’ll ask a few basic questions to get started.
2. Compare Your Options – We’ll show you how much you could save by bundling vs. keeping your policies separate.
3. Customize Your Coverage – Pick the right limits and features for both your auto and renters policies. Our team is here to help.
4. Start Your Bundle – Once you're happy, we’ll finalize the paperwork, combine your policies, and you’re good to go.

You don’t have to cancel anything on your own — we’ll walk you through switching, timing, and even transferring coverage from your old provider if needed.

Remember, bundling isn’t just about saving money (though that’s a huge bonus). It’s about making your insurance life easier — and Defy Insurance is here to help every step of the way.

Still have questions? Our friendly team is just a message or call away.

Bundle and Save – Request a Free Quote Today!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I bundle even if I rent and don’t own a car?

Great question — and the answer is: not really.

The auto and renters insurance bundle specifically works when you have both an auto policy and renters policy with the same provider. If you don’t own a car, bundling in the traditional sense won’t apply. However, there are still discounts and perks you can explore, such as Renters Plus identity theft protection or adding liability coverage for roommates.

That said, the moment you do purchase a car, it’s the perfect time to revisit bundling options with Defy Insurance. We’ll help you set everything up so you get the multi-policy discount right from day one.

What companies offer the best bundle discounts in NJ?

Several well-known providers offer bundling options in New Jersey, including the usual big names — but here’s the catch: not all of them offer personalized help or flexible plans.

At Defy Insurance, we specialize in custom coverage designed for New Jersey residents. We are familiar with the local rules, typical renter needs, and car insurance rates. Plus, we don’t just plug your info into a system — we walk you through the options and make recommendations based on what makes sense for you.

You’ll get access to strong renters coverage, fair auto premiums, and a straightforward auto and renters insurance bundle that doesn’t overcomplicate things. And of course, we’ll apply any multi-policy discounts you’re eligible for.